The Guest List Tug of War

The biggie. The one variable that will drive every other cost. Follow the rule of thirds, be a jerk, and use a police lineup. Here’s how.

Wedding Planning

Your wedding’s guest list is like the world’s supply of crude oil. Its supply and demand will drive every other cost of the global economy (your wedding); it’s contested by every superpower (the bride, the mothers), and it will trigger wars and bloodshed (your fights with the in-laws).

This is it. The biggie. As we’ve mentioned before, the size of your guest list is the one variable that will make or break your wedding’s budget. A few extra guests could mean the difference between an open bar and boxed wine.

Our overriding principle: don’t be afraid to be a jerk. No, not to your family and fiancée, but to any friends you’re worried about inviting. Think of it this way. When you’re not sure if you want to invite a friend, just don’t invite them. It’s that simple.

More specifically, stick to these 10 guidelines:

1. Follow the Rule of Thirds.

Simple, clean, fair, battle-tested. A third of the guests for your family, a third of the guests for her family, and then a third of the guests for your (and her) friends. Will it work out that neatly? Nope, but it’s a good place to start and a tidy, objective method for avoiding tug-of-wars. Obviously this gets more complicated when one family is footing 99% of the bill. Theoretically the rule still applies (according to conventional etiquette), but if the Paying-Family wants to fork over even more money to invite more guests, fine, as long as they’re not shafting the non-payers (i.e. Payers have 100 guests, Non-Payers have 20.) For more on the wedding’s cruel relationship between money and power, click here.

2. Diss your co-workers.

You see these losers enough Monday through Friday. Dump ‘em. All of them; you can’t just invite half your team and ignore the rest. Ditto for your boss. Click here for more on this topic, but unless you work in a crassly political office where everyone sucks up and invites their boss, just abandon the entire lot. How do you get away with this? Next rule.

3. Lie.

It’s what makes the world go ‘round. You must lie, lie, lie. Even on a lavish budget, some people will be snubbed and some feelings will be bruised. You must lie. Consider what the truth would sound like:

“Hey there. I know that you think we have a friendship. And we sort of do…barely. And, sometimes—not often, but every now and then—I enjoy your company. But here’s the deal; my cube is next to your cube. That’s it. If I invite you to my wedding, that will cost me another $100, and that means I’ll need to invite Ted and Sarah and Josh, and I hate those bastards even more than I dislike you. No hard feelings, right?"

Lie. Use two sets of bullshit buzzwords. Just tell them that you’re having a small wedding with only friends of the family. “Friends of the family,” in particular, is a lethal weapon of diplomacy. Chances are these jerk-offs haven’t met anyone in your family so they won’t feel insulted. And make a deal with your fiancée. For the purposes of white lies, you should blame her and she should blame you. Seriously. Back to your co-workers, just tell them, “Ahhww, man. I’d love to invite you. But Sarah made me agree to a strict ‘no co-workers’ policy. Sorry dude.”

For more half-truths, white lies, and other canned “clichés” you should have in your hip pocket, click here.

4. No COGs.

Some wedding-porn suggests that since the ceremony and the reception, technically, are two different events, you can lower costs by inviting some guests just to the ceremony and some lucky-ass VIPs to both events. We’ll give you the courtesy of candor: doing that makes you a dick. It’s awkward and classless. What are your COGs (ceremony only guests) going to do after the bride kisses the groom? Go to a different bar by themselves? Lame.

If you can’t afford to invite someone to the reception, never invite them to the ceremony. It will look like you’re trolling for gifts. The reverse, however, is not true. If you’re getting married in a chapel the size of a meat locker, it’s fine to invite a larger crowd to the reception. I hate to break this to you, but outside of your families and a few unbalanced women, no one gives a rat’s ass about the ceremony itself.

5. Ground the kids.

Easy rule of thumb. Unless they’re immediate family, never invite anyone who hasn’t hit puberty. For more on this, click here.

6. No Maury-Friends.

You know Maury. He’s your annoying friend-of-a-friend from college that borrowed $20 and never gave it back. You haven’t seen him in years. Sometimes he forwards you dumb e-mails. On Facebook he throws “virtual snowballs” at you. Cut him loose. And keep perspective. For every Maury you reject, that gives you another $100 that you can splurge on booze for people you actually like.

7. Tolerate the tools.

On the other hand… you’re not going to like everyone at your wedding. Deal with it. Some people simply have to be invited—annoying cousins, your mother’s best-friend-slash-yoga-instructor, and your bride’s father. Resign yourself to the fact that you’d be secretly, evilly, genuinely happy if 10% of your guests were hit by a bus. This is normal.

8. Limit(?) the Plus Ones.

This one’s tough. It’s the grayest of all the gray areas. According to tradition—which gets less and less relevant by the second—guests only bring a significant other if they’re actually married. Now the more common rule of thumb is if they’re living together. One (sensibile) rule of thumb is that if you've never actually met the date, then you don't need to invite them. Our take? By getting more ruthless elsewhere (co-workers, friends who aren’t really friends, little brats) you’ll be able to be more generous with the plus-ones. Remember, you want your guests to have a relaxed good time, not to get drunk and rush out to a booty call…

9. Involve the parents.

We know, we know, this is pretty damn obvious if they’re paying for the wedding; of course they’ll be involved. But if you’re the ones footing the bill, it might be tempting to bypass Mom and Dad. Don’t. After the bride, this matters more to the mothers than anyone else; make sure you get their input and preferences. Even beyond the scope of “wedding planning,” it’s just being a good(ish) son.

10. Use a Police Lineup.

When my sister got engaged, she agonized over whether to invite Mr. Peterson, an old friend of my father’s. He (my father) asked her if she could recognize Mr. Peterson out of a police lineup. She said she couldn’t. My father said, “Then if you can’t even recognize the guy out of a police lineup, why would you want him at your wedding?” So Mr. Peterson wasn’t invited. No, your parents might not be that reasonable or flexible. But if they are, or if you simply need a compelling way to phrase your objections, the “police lineup” is proven and reliable.

Want a good tool for the guest list management? We've got you covered. Use The Plunge's Badass Guest List Spreadsheet. It's the best in the business, bar none.

Follow The Plunge on Twitter: http://twitter.com/ThePlunge_com

Rate this Article  
Send
Print
Share
 

 

Comments (4)

A Bit of a Compromize

When it came time to start making our guest list we ran into a lot of problems. My fiance and I are paying for most of the wedding ourselves with a small amount of help from my side and some from her side as well. Since we aren't both from the same state it meant that one side would have to travel and we decided that it would be easier for her side to travel. So her families guest list was reasonable and left my mom with about 100 guests our of 165. When I got the list of potential guests from my mom it was over 400 people. Since I am in Afghanistan at the time my fiance was the one doing most of the phone calls and this was driving her crazy. What we did was rate everyone on my mom's list either a 1 (for immediate famil/very very close family friends), 2 (family friends), and 3 (other friends). After she did the rating I went through the list and followed the police line up method somewhat and redid the ratings so that they were more accurate.

We managed to get the list down to the number that we had previously decided on, but the problem that we ran into next was that we still had about 300 guests that my mom felt it was important to invite and she thought that we could just get a tent to put outside the hall that we were renting (the wedding is in ND in May.....it snowed the first week of June this year) but we decided that it would be worse to invite all of them and tell most of them they had to stay outside because of max occupancy laws. So instead we decided to have a much less formal party the week before and my mom is able to invite who ever she wants since they are footing the bill for the whole thing. This has made it so that we can stay within our budget and she can invite who she wants and everyone is happy this way.....and this way we may get more presents (need the cash so we can pay for all of this).
MOTU, October 11, 2009
 

...

LMAO, love it! "outside of your families and a few unbalanced women, no one gives a rat’s ass about the ceremony itself." My fiance and I were thinking about only having our closest friends and parents at the ceremony but then I wondered if the rest of the people would feel left out and weird to just show up for a reception - as if it would be like missing the beginning of the movie or something. But then I also thought, do I want to express personal vows in front of everyone in attendance? Not so much. Thanks for the honest and hilarious post about this.
wedding, November 12, 2009
 

.....

So, I'm the girl with the guys' perspective here... My fiance', Joel, wants the huge wedding, I want the justice of the peace... I've been fighting him like crazy about the guest list, I have 70 people I'm inviting for "my side"... He has over 300 he wants to invite. I am sooo showing him this article... maybe it will help convince him that he does NOT need to invite coworkers from the LAST place he worked.
Elle, March 26, 2010
 

Guest list woes

So me and my dude to be decided to have a really, really small and informal ceremony for our parents and siblings in the home next month, and plan/pay for the real wedding for next year. We were set, until his mom calls me and tells me how disappointed the rest of his family is that they can't come to the small non-wedding. I'm flexible and open, so I listen and I somewhat agree to it. But a few hours later I realized that I've been hoodwinked! And I get pissed. She gave me the story so sweetly too! But we aren't planning the wedding for next month, its really spur of the moment. So nothing is going to be prepared for public viewing. Plus, my folks are 4 states away and can't make it here under such short notice, even if they tried. So I want everyone to come to the wedding. That's what it's for. So now I'm in the position to end up looking like the jerk because I'm either going to argue with him about how he explained this to his family, or argue with them about my stringent non-wedding guest list.....boooo!
T., July 16, 2010
 
smaller | bigger
 Subscribe via email (registered users only)

security image
Write the displayed characters

Submit

busy  
 
Join The Plunge
Unlike a certain someone, we're not asking for a
lifelong commitment. This can stay casual.
Join us and get:
  • Access to the Community
  • To-do reminders (less lame than it sounds)
  • Antidotes to your bride's wedding-porn
Join The Plunge
Join The Plunge
Unlike a certain someone, we're not asking for a
lifelong commitment. This can stay casual.
Join us and get:
  • Access to the Community
  • To-do reminders (less lame than it sounds)
  • Antidotes to your bride's wedding-porn
Join The Plunge
Forum

Know someone getting married? Throw 'em a bone.

Tell a Friend
 
busyLoading Poll...