Formalwear and Tuxes: The Plunge’s 20 Rules
Article Index
Formalwear and Tuxes: The Plunge’s 20 Rules
Page #
All Pages

You don’t have to be a fashion snob. But you need to follow a few rules and ask yourself, WWJBD: What Would James Bond Do?

Groomsmen Tuxedo

Your bride might think it’s a great idea for you to get married in a traditional Scottish Kilt. And the conventional wisdom from wedding-porn is that it’s “your wedding” and that you should choose whatever "formalwear" you please, from a casual navy blazer to a khaki suit to a daring orange tailcoat.

Our take? Chuck all that. Ignore it. Instead, stick to this one guiding principle: WWJBD—What Would James Bond Do? Bond would never tolerate the indignity of getting stuffed in a peach cummerbund; he’d demand simplicity, formality...black.

If you drool over GQ every month (the fashion articles, not the models) and obsess over the latest trends from Milan, go ahead and skip this article and start picking the music for the reception. You’re set. Everyone else? Closely follow The Plunge’s 20 rules on formalwear.

General Principles

1. Buy the damn thing. Chances are if you’re getting married so are a ton of your friends. The tux will pay for itself in three to four events. Financially, this is the least painful time in your life to fork over hundreds (or thousands) of dollars for the tux; and if your fiancée can spend $3,000 on a dress that she’ll only wear once, why can’t you spend $700 on something you’ll wear repeatedly? Fair’s fair. You might even get someone else to pick up the tab.

2. Don’t rely on a list like this. Don’t rely on any website. And for God’s sake, don’t rely on your own taste. Instead, find someone you trust at the store who will put you in an excellent tux. You know who we’re talking about—the stylish, well-groomed salesman who speaks English as a second language. Rely on this guy.

3. Find a good tailor. Not any random dude from Walma-Suit. Just because you buy the suit somewhere doesn’t mean you need to use their (free) tailor. If you already use someone else for your suits then for God’s sake pay a little extra and take it to them. If not, ask around for recommendations. Chances are your fiancée already has a tailor on her list of contacts.

4. Coordinate with the bride. She’ll “have some thoughts” about how your tuxes will meld into her aesthetic vision. Luckily, by now this rule should be obvious; you can’t wipe your ass without coordinating with bridezilla.

5. Remember your boys. For the past year you’ve been spending Monopoly Money. Even if you’re paying for the wedding, it doesn’t feel like normal cash; it’s coming from a surreal wedding budget. $700 for you is not the same thing as $700 for your groomsmen. It’s fine to splurge on your own tux—recommended, even—but make sure they have an affordable option.

6. Geography matters. If your groomsmen live in other cities, consider using a tux shop with a national presence. Alternatively, you can have your buddy from Shit Flip, Idaho get measured locally and pick his tux up elsewhere. Just keep this in mind.

7. Strike early. Like a trip to the dentist, there’s nothing to be gained by pushing things off. The toothache will only get more painful, not less. Plus, the earlier you get this root canal, the more time you have to recover in case Pothead Chucky (your best man) screws up the order.

8. Never overshadow the bride. This is impossible if you follow our advice—timeless over trendy, black, classic—but it bears repeating... because she will kill you if you look better than her. (Just look at those hideous dresses she picked out for her friends.)

9. A suit can work in a pinch. It can be done. Just make sure that it’s perfectly fitted, matches your groomsmen, and that your tie incorporates the wedding’s color scheme. (Jesus. Did we just say “wedding’s color scheme?” Slap us.)

10. Relax. In the grand scheme of things, no one gives a rat’s ass what you wear. Have you ever heard someone say, “Did you see Rachel’s wedding? I just adored the groom’s lapels!” People notice your bride. They’ll whisper about her dress, swoon over her haircut, gush about her overall beauty. (Or they’ll bitchily snicker about her shortcomings. You’ll never know.) As long as you keep things simple and make sure your clothes fit—not a hard job—you’ve done your job.

11. Don’t mindlessly follow the rules. Look, even 007 knows there are times to follow and times to break the rules. A destination wedding in Hawaii gives you a lot of leeway. But we are not going to be weenies and tell you “either way, it’s your day so you can’t go wrong.” You can go horribly, horribly wrong. On the other hand, no one likes a fashion snob. So take all of this under advisory, but if you feel strongly about wearing a top-hat and tails, fine, “it’s your big day”. Thumb your nose at convention. Remember, in this life you’ll only get married a few times.

Rules 12-20 on the next page...


Fashion Advice

 

12. Think long-term. You know when you flip open a wedding album from the 70s, you see disco ruffled tuxes and leopard-print jackets? If you make any “creative” or “fashion-forward” choices that embrace the current trends, this will be you in 2024. Memorize this tongue-twister: Timeless trumps trendy.

13. Go easy on the colors. It’s impossible to go wrong with black and white. It’s classic. It conveys the weight of formality. When you experiment with the color of your tux, you look like Jim Carrey at the end of Dumb and Dumber. (Caveat: colors like “midnight blue” and “charcoal” fall into the category of black and white. Welcome to the insanity of fashion.)

14. No pleats. Your pants should be flat-fronted. For reasons that defy explanation, our society wore pleats throughout the 80s and 90s, even though they made every non-Olympian look fatter. That era of madness is over. Only wear pleats if you’re actively trying to look like a tubby old man.

15. Go with simple shirts and collars. The “wing” collar is the most traditional choice (with the points shooting up). Guess what: Bond would not be caught dead in one. Our recommendation—a turndown or spread collar. For more on the other options—turndown collar, spread collar, crosswyck, banded collar—click here. Regarding shirts, go for as plain a shirt as you can stand. You need not ruffle.

16. Watch the cut and fit. Different cuts and combinations work better for different body types. This tuxedo shop has some good rules of thumb. The highlights:

Short and slender guys: Single breasted jackets with long lines. (Ignore their comments about double-pleated pants.)

Short and stocky guys: Make sure the collar is slim. Absolutely no cummerbunds (you’ll look even stockier.) The top button should “fall at the small of the waist to give the torso a leaner look.”

Tall and muscular guys: Go with classic single-breasted. The double-breasted jacket will make you look too bulky.

Tall and slim guys: You can pretty much get away with anything. The classic single-breasted is probably the best option; the double-breasted will also work (always button it up).

The cut matters. If the jacket almost fits and you have the option of widening the shoulders for forty bucks—but you think maybe you can just squeak by without alteration—open your wallet and spend the dough. You always look better in a properly-fitted suit, whether you have the physique of Tony Romo or Tony Siragusa.

17. Skip the cummerbund or vest. Heresy? So be it. A great tux does not need a cummerbund unless you have one of those shirts where the ruffles stop halfway down like a napkin. You should not wear one of those shirts, ergo, you don’t need a cummerbund. And colorful cummerbunds that match the bridesmaid dresses, while common, smack of prom and homecoming. Same for vests.

18. The bow tie is optional. Seriously. In fact, think long and hard before wearing one. Is it allowed? Sure. Millions have. Millions will. However, almost no one with style wears a bow tie anymore; it was even ditched by Tucker Carlson. If you decide to wear one, make sure that you tie it yourself. This is critical. Nothing screws up a look like the side clip showing through your collar. Here’s how to tie it.

19. Break in your shoes. Don't skip this. First, buy a new pair of shoes for the wedding (more in a minute). Don’t wear your work shoes, wingtips, or normal dress shoes. To repeat: no wingtips. More importantly, you are going to be standing all night—make sure you break them in well before the wedding. What kind to buy? Simple and black. If you wear tassels we reserve the right to ambush your wedding and sucker-punch you in the heart. Do you need patent leather (the shiny ones)? No. Just as long as they are polished, simple, and black.

20. Less is more. Think of “fashion boldness” like salt: a little will add some flavor, a lot will spoil the dish. If your entire ensemble is classic—simple jacket, pants, tie--then you can add one spicy element (a crimson flower boutonnière, say) and it will pop.

For some more advice, check out the counsel at Men’s Warehouse and GQ’s “How to Buy a Tux.”

And thus concludes your official Groom Duties. For more on the actual Wedding Planning, click here.

Follow The Plunge on Twitter: http://twitter.com/ThePlunge_com

Rate this Article  
Send
Print
Share
 

 

Comments (9)

One additional point...

I'd add, "consider the venue!" I'm getting married in an outdoor ceremony. In South Florida. In June. Yes, it's the bride's idea, and no, it's not one of those things that was worth getting in a fight over. I got her to concede to a 30-minute max time limit on the ceremony before we go to the hotel --and air conditioning -- for the reception, so that's my victory.

At any rate, I'll be wearing a pair of light linen pants, linen shirt, and a very light cotton sport coat. And sandals. The groomsmen? Same outfit, sans coat. A tuxedo would be tortuously hot in those circumstances, and we don't want my guys passing out from heatstroke.

You don't have to get hitched in a monkey-suit, if you don't want one.
corkdork, June 17, 2009
 

Do NOT buy the tux!

I have to say, buying the tux is a TERRIBLE idea. I've been in 5 weddings and watched 5 brides spend an entire year leading up to the wedding making themselves hysterical over every possible detail. Tuxedoes have different styles, different vests ... you CANNOT re-use the tux in another wedding. The bride will have already chosen a style of tux, and even if your tux is 99.9% identical to her tux, she will go INSANE if you try to wear something different to her wedding. The style won't be the same, the vest won't have the wedding colors, and you won't be identical to the other groomsmen for pictures. Unfortunately, if you're in 5 weddings, you have to rent 5 tuxes. That's just the way it is.
gwiereng, June 18, 2009
 

...

Granted, you most likely can not use the tux in another wedding as a groomsen if the bride has a vision of matching groomsment. However, if you buy a classic tuxedo you will be able to wear it any black tie event you are asked to attend as a guest for as long
as it fits. For example I have had my tuxedo for 8 years and it has served me well countless times, including as a groomsmen in my brothers wedding (bride was not picky about matching groomsmen).
David, June 19, 2009
 

...

I agree. I wear my tuxedo to a wide array of black tie events. First Look for Charity at the Chicago Auto show, Opening Night Gala at the Chicago Symphony Orchestra, etc. You can change up the vest and tie for a pretty small amount and keep the white shirt and black tux. It can really save you some money if you go to a lot of black tie events. If you're like most of my firends however...it may not be worth it.
ckalecki, July 27, 2009
 

Bow ties are mandatory

Bow ties are optional? Sounds like you guys need to take your own advice: Go for the timeless, classic look, not the style of the day.

WWJBD? Well, he sure as hell wouldn't dress like Casey Affleck on Oscar night. http://www.esquire.com/style/b...ars-2008-9
B Dubs, September 22, 2009
 

Just Hire

I just hired the tuxes, was less hassle and much cheaper, then i just gave each male member of the wedding party a pair of cufflinks i got off www.weddingcufflinks.net
Simon, December 14, 2009
 

Must wear a waist covering!!

Formalwear is all about the details. A cummerbund or a low-cut waistcoat shows you pay attention to detail. No waist covering or a high-cut vest shows you dont know what you're doing.

Men do not have to follow rules for dress very often. If you have to wear black tie, please cover your waist and wear a self-tie bow tie.
Sajidov3, January 13, 2010
 

no vest?

i absolutely agree w/ everything above, except the no-vests. if nothing else, the wedding porn my fiance has some good points about menswear. for those of us not blessed with the above-listed slim and muscular frames, black vests are a welcome alternative to looking (and feeling) fat. a good vest w/ a good cut and possible some kind of vertical stripe can really help downplay any...shall we say, extra, around the middle. just because i'm a dude doesn't mean i don't care about looking fat...altho i agree that colored vests (anything besides neutrals) are a big no. just, no.
gandalfnerd, April 06, 2010
 

This is perfectly fine

You guys who are railing against no cummerbund or bow tie seem paralyzed by even the *thought* of not doing it like your dad did way back when. Can you throw any black tie in with any tuxedo? No. If you bought one of those stupid ruffly shirts can you skip the cummerbund? No. If you actually take a few minutes and put an outfit together, can a spread collar and black necktie look awesome? Absolutely. If you think I am full of crap, then you probably still have the tasseled loafers that your dad wears, too. It's time to update, gentlemen.
bwherman, April 10, 2010
 
smaller | bigger
 Subscribe via email (registered users only)

security image
Write the displayed characters

Submit

busy  
 
Join The Plunge
Unlike a certain someone, we're not asking for a
lifelong commitment. This can stay casual.
Join us and get:
  • Access to the Community
  • To-do reminders (less lame than it sounds)
  • Antidotes to your bride's wedding-porn
Join The Plunge
Join The Plunge
Unlike a certain someone, we're not asking for a
lifelong commitment. This can stay casual.
Join us and get:
  • Access to the Community
  • To-do reminders (less lame than it sounds)
  • Antidotes to your bride's wedding-porn
Join The Plunge
Forum

Know someone getting married? Throw 'em a bone.

Tell a Friend
 
busyLoading Poll...